Healthcare involves highly personal and private information, including medical records, diagnoses, treatment plans, and other sensitive details. While beneficial in many contexts, the blockchain's inherent transparency and immutability can become a double-edged sword when dealing with such sensitive data.
Considerations before integrating blockchain technology
Healthcare organizations typically have complex IT infrastructures, including electronic health records (EHRs), medical billing systems, and other legacy systems. Incorporating blockchain into this ecosystem while ensuring seamless interoperability is necessary for its successful adoption. The transition may require significant investments in terms of time and expertise. This can be costly, especially for healthcare organizations with limited resources.
Before using blockchain technology, the possibility of complex implementation and costs should be thoroughly considered.
See also: The guide to HIPAA compliant text messaging
Blockchain challenges for healthcare organizations
Public blockchain
Data privacy: Public blockchains are designed to be transparent, allowing anyone to view transaction details. This transparency poses a significant challenge in healthcare as medical information, particularly patient data, should remain confidential. HIPAA mandates strict privacy and security measures to protect patient information, making public blockchains incompatible with HIPAA requirements.
Private blockchain
Interoperability: Healthcare involves various stakeholders, including hospitals, insurers, pharmacies, and research institutions. Achieving interoperability between different private blockchains used by these entities is necessary for efficient data exchange.
Data standardization: HIPAA requires consistent data formats and terminologies to ensure accurate and meaningful data exchange. Achieving data standardization across multiple private blockchains used by different organizations may be difficult, impacting the effectiveness of data sharing and collaboration.
Centralization concerns: While private blockchains offer more control over data access and governance, concerns may arise regarding data ownership and centralization of control. HIPAA requires clear data ownership and accountability, and private blockchains must ensure compliance with these requirements.
Consortium blockchain
Governance and consensus: Consortium blockchains involve multiple entities, each with its interests and objectives. Achieving consensus among all participants can be challenging, especially when their interests differ. Effective governance is necessary to establish rules and protocols that align with HIPAA requirements.
Data sharing: Balancing the need for data sharing and collaboration with the privacy requirements of participating organizations is a delicate task. HIPAA requires strict control over data access and sharing, which must be effectively managed within the consortium blockchain context.
Onboarding and participation: Convincing healthcare organizations to join and actively participate in the consortium requires addressing their concerns about adopting new technologies and ensuring HIPAA compliance. Encouraging participation and commitment to compliance is required for the success of the consortium blockchain.
Navigating the challenges associated with using blockchain
For starters, healthcare providers must assess the suitability of different blockchain types for their specific use cases. Public blockchains, with their transparency and lack of control, might not be the best fit for sensitive medical data. Instead, private or consortium blockchains could offer better data access control while maintaining decentralization to some extent.
Integrating blockchain technology with existing systems and applications can facilitate data exchange and interoperability, reducing implementation complexities and ensuring a smoother transition to blockchain-based solutions. Furthermore, patient consent and data sharing require transparent and auditable mechanisms on blockchain networks. User-friendly interfaces and educational campaigns can help patients understand the implications of what sharing their data on a blockchain could cause and provide clear options for granting and revoking consent.
See also: HIPAA Compliant Email: The Definitive Guide
Kirsten Peremore
